By RustToRedemption: Could be, but unlikely. The battery was brand new, and then was on a tender when it wasn't being used. I verified battery charge with a voltmeter prior to trying to get it to start the second time in case I had zonked the battery (I hadn't).
Even if new, I would do a simple headlight high beam load test (engine off). Charging can give a battery a surface charge that tests normal on your multimeter, but if the battery is bad, the load test voltage will drop significantly lower. The test is easy & eliminates an unknown. A digital multimeter is preferable for these voltage checks. I use a VC97 digital multimeter & Ctek US 0.8 smart charger.
...